| A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M |
| N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z |
Name   |
Location |
Market price |
Quest | Members Only |
| Personal totem | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Pineappletini | Randomly obtained while participating in any of the activities at the Summer Beach Party event. | --- | No | No |
| Polly | Can be bought from the Rare token store for 7,000 tokens. | --- | No | No |
| Pontifex censer | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Pontifex crozier | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Pontifex Maximus figurine | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Pontifex mitre | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Portable phylactery | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Portent of passage IV | Player made (See notes section). | --- | No | Yes |
| Praetorian hood | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Praetorian robes | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Praetorian staff | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Protective goggles | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Prototype godbow | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Prototype godstaff | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Prototype godsword | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Prototype gravimeter | Unknown, please submit. | --- | No | Yes |
| Pulse core | Possible reward from Treasure Hunter minigame. | --- | No | Yes |
| Purrn of previous postcat | Received upon completion of the Cats of Menaphos activity. | --- | No | Yes |
