|Blood rune (40-60)||Coins (8,414–14,975)||Dragon arrowheads (21–30)||Dragon battleaxe|
|Dragon bolt tips (50–88)||Dragon dart tip (20–30)||Elder charm||Elder energy (64–82)|
|Muspah spine (1–2)||Nightmare gauntlets||Off-hand rune claw||Rune 2h sword (2 Noted)|
|Rune claw||Shark (2)||Soul rune (20-29)||Steel titan pouch|
|Summoning potion (4)||Super strength (4)||Unicorn stallion pouch|
When fighting Nightmares, they primarily use Melee; so protect/deflect from Melee or use of Soul split is suggested. At some points you will notice their hands come together and they hurl a black ball at you. At this point it is advised to switch to protect/deflect from Ranged regardless of what prayer/curse you were using before. Failing to do such can cause you to be hit with 4,000 damage.